FA Value - How much?

[Couch-Potato]

Sooooo how much do we expect our FAs to be valued at this offseason? How many years and at what cost?

CB
Nazeeh Johnson

DE
Charles Omenihu
Tershawn Wharton
Malik Herring

DT
Derrick Nnadi
Mike Pennel
Marlon Tuipulotu

G
Mike Caliendo
Trey Smith

LB
Nick Bolton
Jack Cochrane

LS
James Winchester

LT
DJ Humphries

OLB
Josh Uche

QB
Carson Wentz

RB
Samaje Perine
Kareem Hunt

S
Justin Reid

WR
DeAndre Hopkins
Marquise Brown
Justin Watson
JuJu Smith-Schuster
Mecole Hardman

[Hoover]

Smith is the only one who is going to bring much in terms of compensatory picks.

Wharton and Charles O should get OK money. Same for Bolton, but I expect to keep one of them

[kccrow]

Looking at vet min, tenders, valuations by Spotrac and OTC, and relative market conditions, this would be my estimate:

Pos Player Age Accrued Seasons Type Estimated Value
CB Keith Taylor 26 3 RFA $1,100,000
CB Nazeeh Johnson 26 3 RFA $1,100,000
DE Charles Omenihu 27 6 UFA $11,500,000
DE Malik Herring 27 3 RFA $1,100,000
DE Tershawn Wharton 26 5 UFA $7,500,000
DT Derrick Nnadi 28 7 UFA $1,255,000
DT Marlon Tuipulotu 25 4 UFA $1,170,000
DT Mike Pennel 33 10 UFA $1,500,000
LB Jack Cochrane 25 3 RFA $1,100,000
LB Nick Bolton 24 4 UFA $12,000,000
LS James Winchester 35 10 UFA $1,255,000
LT DJ Humphries 31 10 UFA $3,500,000
OG Mike Caliendo 27 2 ERFA $1,030,000
OG Trey Smith 25 4 UFA $21,000,000
OLB Josh Uche 26 5 UFA $1,500,000
P Matt Araiza 24 1 ERFA $960,000
QB Carson Wentz 32 9 UFA $3,250,000
RB Kareem Hunt 29 8 UFA $2,000,000
RB Samaje Perine 29 8 UFA $1,500,000
S Justin Reid 27 7 UFA $15,000,000
TE Baylor Cupp 24 1 SFA $960,000
TE Jody Fortson 29 4 UFA $1,170,000
TE Peyton Hendershot 25 3 RFA $1,100,000
WR DeAndre Hopkins 32 12 UFA $8,000,000
WR JuJu Smith-Schuster 28 8 UFA $1,750,000
WR Justin Watson 28 7 UFA $1,750,000
WR Marquise Brown 27 6 UFA $8,000,000
WR Mecole Hardman 26 6 UFA $1,170,000
K Spencer Shrader 25 1 ERFA $960,000

[Couch-Potato]

I think you’re pretty spot on there Crow.

Brown and Hopkins are tough evals, one didn’t play all season and the other’s aging.

Omenihu was also out all season and he’s the toughest decision for me, I like what he brings, but just not sure what his true value is.

[kccrow]

As a reference point, here are RFA tenders:

Type Amount
First Round $7,279,000
Second Round $5,217,000
Right of First Refusal $3,185,000

I don't know that we would tender anyone at 3.2 m on our list. Maybe Hendershot if Kelce retires.

Heres is the vet minimums:

AS 2025
0 $840,000
1 $960,000
2 $1,030,000
3 $1,100,000
4 $1,170,000
5 $1,170,000
6 $1,170,000
7 $1,255,000
8 $1,255,000
9 $1,255,000
10 $1,255,000

[kccrow]

Originally Posted by Couch-Potato

I think you’re pretty spot on there Crow.

Brown and Hopkins are tough evals, one didn’t play all season and the other’s aging.

Omenihu was also out all season and he’s the toughest decision for me, I like what he brings, but just not sure what his true value is.

I looked at Hopkins at a Adam Thielen type level.
Brown is a tossup but the talent is there. I can't help but think and equivalent to this year is possible but it's his last chance if he doesn't play a full slate at a high level.

The market levels were interesting from Spotrac. Pretty in line with most of my thoughts. They had Hopkins at around 15m. Reid was around 17m. The rest were fairly close to what I have.

[Couch-Potato]

Originally Posted by kccrow

I looked at Hopkins at a Adam Thielen type level.
Brown is a tossup but the talent is there. I can't help but think and equivalent to this year is possible but it's his last chance if he doesn't play a full slate at a high level.

The market levels were interesting from Spotrac. Pretty in line with most of my thoughts. They had Hopkins at around 15m. Reid was around 17m. The rest were fairly close to what I have.

Whoa! Those are loft #’s for Hop and Reid!

Would 1000% understand if they had to leave for offers like that.