Geno Smith is not worth the 1st overall pick

[CoMoChief]

Alex Smith v2.0

[Bowser]

Originally Posted by DomerNKC

dont forget he puked all over himself and caused his team to suffer two, count them TWO safetys in one game! The biggest game of his career and he laid an egg against the MIGHTY SYRACUSE and their incredible 8-5 record. National powerhouse team. Lets go jump on a guy that folds in the sight of a big game. Hell going 5-0 to start the season created enough pressure to push him to a 2-5 finish. At least his defense could be blamed for a lot of that flame out. His collapse in the bowl game was proof of HIS ineptitude. We need to pass on geno "joey harrington" smith. He would be worth the third round pick he is worthy of because he has upside and with some seasoning could be a decent backup. Of course he will probably throw a grapefruit 80 yards from his knees during private workouts and people will go crazy like they
did with jamarcus. Geno #1 overall is a flipping joke. I have no clue who should be #1 at this point, but geno isnt it.

Yeah, let's blame Geno for shitty playcalling, playing in a blizzard, and having one of the worst defenses in the country.

He doesn't have the national pull that Luck and RGIII did. Must not be worthy of the top pick. Brilliant.

I guess you missed where Geno went to Norman and put up 49 on the Sooners in their house?

[SAUTO]

Domer has been to busy giving dome to know what a qb looks like.

Please don't berate me now Burt, sorry if I hurt bubby's feelings
Posted via Mobile Device

[SAUTO]

Originally Posted by Bowser

Yeah, let's blame Geno for shitty playcalling, playing in a blizzard, and having one of the worst defenses in the country.

He doesn't have the national pull that Luck and RGIII did. Must not be worthy of the top pick. Brilliant.

I guess you missed where Geno went to Norman and put up 49 on the Sooners in their house?

But he gave up that last score and caused the loss...


Undraftable
Posted via Mobile Device

[Bowser]

Originally Posted by B_Ambuehl

There are better ways of managing the draft that could get you a QB without spending the #1 pick on one who isn't worth it.

Your way of "managing the draft" would net us a quarterback that has a lower ceiling than Geno. Pass.

Just for shits and giggles, who IS worth the #1 pick this year?

[Baby Lee]

Originally Posted by chop

I'm not sure that Geno Smith is worthy of the #1 pick but I do remember people saying similar stuff about RGIII last year. Many people thought RGIII was going to drop to the Chiefs pick at this time last year. The closer the draft got the higher RGIII was rated. I'm not saying that Geno is going to move up the same as RGIII but there may be another QB that everyone falls in love with later.

Why do people continue to propagate this revisionist history.

Luck and RGIII were never anything but 1&2 in the draft. The only commotion was 'sure Luck is a can't miss, once in a generation, no brainer, franchise QB, but is it possible that RGIII is JUST AS GOOD, . . . or BETTER?'

[Saccopoo]

Originally Posted by chop

I'm not sure that Geno Smith is worthy of the #1 pick but I do remember people saying similar stuff about RGIII last year. Many people thought RGIII was going to drop to the Chiefs pick at this time last year. The closer the draft got the higher RGIII was rated. I'm not saying that Geno is going to move up the same as RGIII but there may be another QB that everyone falls in love with later.

And this is the stupid thing.

Geno has three years of starting game tape. He's played against top level defenses that featured NFL first rounders.

The Texas and OU games alone should be enough, let alone games like LSU or the Orange Bowl the year before.

Like the combine is going to change anything that Geno has done to this point in his career. Like a single post season All-Star game with three days of practice is going to mean anything.

Hell, Cam Newton threw the ugliest, most inaccurate balls I've ever seen in a structured setting at his combine and he went #1 overall and was NFL rookie of the year.

[Saccopoo]

Originally Posted by B_Ambuehl

There are better ways of managing the draft that could get you a QB without spending the #1 pick on one who isn't worth it.

Sure there is, but Geno Smith is so worth it.

Ideal size, superb accuracy, doesn't put the ball into the defenses hands, excellent pocket awareness, near perfect release that is exceptionally fast, good athletic ability, very good arm, etc.

Tell me why Geno isn't worth the first pick and then tell me who you think is worth the #1 overall pick if Geno isn't. Please. Pretty please.

[Crush]

Originally Posted by Baby Lee

Why do people continue to propagate this revisionist history.

Luck and RGIII were never anything but 1&2 in the draft. The only commotion was 'sure Luck is a can't miss, once in a generation, no brainer, franchise QB, but is it possible that RGIII is JUST AS GOOD, . . . or BETTER?'

Kiper had RGIII at no. 19 before the combine. Another truefan myth shot down.

http:// http://espn.go.com/blog/big12/post/_/id/35949/rg3-debuts-on-mel-kipers-big-board

[KC native]

Originally Posted by CoMoChief

I'm not necessarily anti-Geno.....I just don't think he's worth the 1st overall pick.

That settles it. Geno is worth the #1 pick.

[SAUTO]

Originally Posted by Baby Lee

Why do people continue to propagate this revisionist history.

Luck and RGIII were never anything but 1&2 in the draft. The only commotion was 'sure Luck is a can't miss, once in a generation, no brainer, franchise QB, but is it possible that RGIII is JUST AS GOOD, . . . or BETTER?'

Are you serious?

At this point they were 1 2.

A couple Weeks prior it wasn't such a sure thug
Posted via Mobile Device

[Crush]

Originally Posted by DomerNKC

dont forget he puked all over himself and caused his team to suffer two, count them TWO safetys in one game! The biggest game of his career and he laid an egg against the MIGHTY SYRACUSE and their incredible 8-5 record. National powerhouse team. Lets go jump on a guy that folds in the sight of a big game. Hell going 5-0 to start the season created enough pressure to push him to a 2-5 finish. At least his defense could be blamed for a lot of that flame out. His collapse in the bowl game was proof of HIS ineptitude. We need to pass on geno "joey harrington" smith. He would be worth the third round pick he is worthy of because he has upside and with some seasoning could be a decent backup. Of course he will probably throw a grapefruit 80 yards from his knees during private workouts and people will go crazy like they
did with jamarcus. Geno #1 overall is a flipping joke. I have no clue who should be #1 at this point, but geno isnt it.

You are so ****ing stupid that it makes my head hurt. Last year's Orange Bowl was the biggest game of his career.

[htismaqe]

Originally Posted by Baby Lee

Why do people continue to propagate this revisionist history.

Luck and RGIII were never anything but 1&2 in the draft. The only commotion was 'sure Luck is a can't miss, once in a generation, no brainer, franchise QB, but is it possible that RGIII is JUST AS GOOD, . . . or BETTER?'

RG3 wasn't #2 until AFTER THE COMBINE.

As someone already showed, Kiper had him 19th.

McShay had him THIRTY FIRST at this time last year.

[htismaqe]

Originally Posted by B_Ambuehl

There are better ways of managing the draft that could get you a QB without spending the #1 pick on one who isn't worth it.

Wow, just wow. When did you become a True Fan?

[mdstu]

Hopefully we can add this prediction to this thread.

http://www.chiefsplanet.com/BB/showt...ight=CoMoChief

[Molitoth]

So far I haven't read any legit argument as to why we shouldn't draft geno.