Fantasy Football. Josh Allen or Jonathan Taylor

[TripleThreat]

Simple, PPR League - Jonathan Taylor or Josh Allen?

[TripleThreat]

Originally Posted by Mecca

Your RB's should be fine although you'll have some bad weeks because they can be hit or miss...those WR's though eesh.

Yeah in 14 league its really picking one or the other. If I don't take Josh Allen, I'm replacing him with Jonathan Taylor and replacing Kamara with Rashee Rice since most of or league goes off expert rankings (yahoo)

I Just don't see the value from going from Josh Allen > JT & Kamara > Rashee

I just have to try to hit on some sleeper WR's in the bench and if any week goes bad, I pray its week 1 or week 2 to pick up a WR in the form of 2023 Kyren and/or Puka.

[mr. tegu]

Originally Posted by TripleThreat

I did a 14 with taking josh Allen Round 1 and got below:

QB: Josh Allen
WR: Chris Godwin
WR: Dionate Johnson
RB: Travis Ettiene
RB: James Cook
TE: Kyle Pitts
Flex: Alvin Kamara


I really like this team tbh in a 14 man league, what do you think? ( I think I can get even better value at some of these spots because our league goes QB/TE early/Family league so bunch of idiots lmao)

If those are your WR just call it quits now. You would be much better off with Amon Ra and someone like Stroud or Love as your QB1.

[Mecca]

I hope you drafted some sleeper WRs

[mr. tegu]

On that mock to illustrate further, Goff, Purdy, Love and Mayfield were all closer to Allen last season than Godwin or Johnson was to Amon Ra.

[Mile High Mania]

Originally Posted by TripleThreat

I did a 14 with taking josh Allen Round 1 and got below:

QB: Josh Allen
WR: Chris Godwin
WR: Dionate Johnson
RB: Travis Ettiene
RB: James Cook
TE: Kyle Pitts
Flex: Alvin Kamara

I really like this team tbh in a 14 man league, what do you think? ( I think I can get even better value at some of these spots because our league goes QB/TE early/Family league so bunch of idiots lmao)

Should have said it's a family league earlier... likely littered with people you love but are casual sports fans? If that's the case, you should have a much better team no matter where you pick.

I'm not sold on the Allen first strategy... but the team I drafted would crush the one you drafted.

QB: Allen
RB: D Achane
RB: T Spears
WR: J Waddle
WR: C Kirk
TE: D Kincaid
Flex: T McLaurin

I look at that team and imagine the top RB or WR in R1, paired with Tua or even Trevor later on... replace Allen with Tua and Spears with J Taylor and that's a hell of a team. Allen/Spears vs Tua/Taylor essentially... that's the opportunity cost of taking Allen at 6 overall. I took Spears as RB2 in R7 just before Tua was drafted.

QB: Tua
RB: J Taylor
RB: D Achane
WR: J Waddle
WR: C Kirk
TE: D Kincaid
Flex: T McLaurin

[TripleThreat]

Originally Posted by Mile High Mania

Should have said it's a family league earlier... likely littered with people you love but are casual sports fans? If that's the case, you should have a much better team no matter where you pick.

I'm not sold on the Allen first strategy... but the team I drafted would crush the one you drafted.

QB: Allen
RB: D Achane
RB: T Spears
WR: J Waddle
WR: C Kirk
TE: D Kincaid
Flex: T McLaurin

I look at that team and imagine the top RB or WR in R1, paired with Tua or even Trevor later on... replace Allen with Tua and Spears with J Taylor and that's a hell of a team. Allen/Spears vs Tua/Taylor essentially... that's the opportunity cost of taking Allen at 6 overall. I took Spears as RB2 in R7 just before Tua was drafted.

QB: Tua
RB: J Taylor
RB: D Achane
WR: J Waddle
WR: C Kirk
TE: D Kincaid
Flex: T McLaurin

Thanks!! Yeah I’m really trying to reevaluate what I want to do. I like the WR’s later in the draft, but I feel the same about RB’s like gus Edwards and Jerome ford.