Quote:
Originally Posted by chiefzilla1501
I think Alex Smith is the best guy to win us some games quickly. By a mile. I like him better than Matt Moore.
But yeah... I don't think his window is 5 years and I don't think he wins us a Super Bowl. I'm only happy with the Alex Smith trade if he gets us winning again and we have a different QB in 3 years, unless he makes a big transformation.
|
I think Alex is better than Matt Moore, but I think winning it all is the ultimate goal and giving up two premium picks for the difference between the two is a huge waste of resources.
A team with Matt Moore and two second round talents is better than Alex without those players.
Both scenarios have replaceable quarterbacks, but one scenario has two additional quality players on it when the QB is replaced.