[BigMeatballDave]

Originally Posted by milkman

Kosar was a solid QB, but never on the level of Manning.

Brees and Rivers were jsut starting out when they played for Marty.

He never worked with either in their primes.

That's a terrible comparison.

But I'll tell you, and I've siad this before, both Marty and Manning could have benefitted from working with each other.

Mrty never in his career had a QB that he could trust with the offense like he could have with Manning, and Manning never had a strong leader like Marty at HC.

I firmly believe that Marty would have overcome his fear of losing, and would have loosened his conservative grip on Mannig and allowed his offfenses to play to win with Manning, while Marty would have had a strong voice that would have demanded a bit more balance on offense, which would have benefitted the entire team.

I hated Marty, but I believe he was a better coach than Tony Dungy.

Like I said, Dungy was just Herman ****ing Edwards with an elite QB.

So Marty's and Peyton's penchant for choking would cancel each other out?