I don't disagree with too much of what walter has to say. Berry was obviously the right pick. But a safety in the top 5... Eh. I'd give it a B+...
McCluster**** would be a D in my book. We took a 170 lb roleplayer whose shelf life is likely under five years when there are a number of everydown improvements on the board, including a QB whom your QB expert has worked with extensively and is telling you has the makings of a franchise player?
At 2B, we could have had golden tate or cody... But we go with a midget nickleback/return specialist? What's the point of drafting Berry at five if you don't plan to man him up in nickle situations?
I like the Asamoah pick. Good value at a position of need. Certainly an A.
Then we trade up and take a player who can't stay healthy at a position that isn't even used in our offense.
And we pass on Cam Thomas in the fifth? Wtf...
|