Quote:
Originally Posted by Sassy Squatch
Teams will analyze the medicals differently, and some won't take him regardless of how they look
|
Which means they aren't clean.
It's like marriage -- if you have to ask, the answer is probably no.
If there's room for significant disagreement with the medicals, he's not a 1st rounder, IMO.
Because I will again reiterate that I don't think he was THAT great a prospect before the injury. He was good -- probably top 15. Not ahead of Campbell, IMO. Maybe not ahead of Membou.
I'm not taking a massive medical risk on an injury of that significance for a 15 spot discount. This isn't a Jeffrey Simmons situation where I thought that guy was a damn monster before the injury.
I thought Josh Simmons was...fine. A good prospect. But not someone we don't see in a lot of years and someone that goes in that 12-18 range. With that kind of injury risk and "medicals being evaluated differently" that's a guy I put in the back of the 2nd into the middle of the 3rd.