Quote:
Originally Posted by staylor26
Yup, that's what I said.
There's really no point in arguing with somebody that is being this disingenuous. Anybody else would fully understand my point and likely concede.
You are sitting here trying to argue that it's not more like that a SB winning HC that was a great OC doesn't have a better shot at identifying a QB than a SB winning HC that was a great DC.
McCarthy developed Flynn and made him look good enough for the Seahawks to pay him to be a starter. That's not shit and yet that alone is more than Tomlin has ever done. Tomlin is a 0 when it comes to ability to identify talent. It's not a stretch to say McCarthy is at least a 1 or even a .5. Tomlin is a defensive guy, it's not even his ****ing wheelhouse.
|
No, you’re arguing that an offensive-minded coach would have a better shot at identifying and drafting a QB.
I’m arguing that we’re discussing Head Coaches here, not GMs. We do not know nearly enough about any of these team’s internal operations to place blame at the HC’s feet for missing on the QB drafting crapshoot.