Quote:
Originally Posted by BroncoBuff
But you're all welcome to my statistical analyses of:
2) John Elway vs Aaron Rodgers careers. By coincidence, this very week they have practically identical career W-L regular season records, though Rodgers has significantly better stats and four MVP awards. Still, Aaron has 6 playoff 'one-and-dones' in 11 Playoff apprentices, he's 1-4 in NFCCGs, and made just one Super Bowl. OTOH, John is 5-2 in AFCCGs, 2-3 in Super Bowls, one League MVP, one SB MVP, and three 'one-and-dones.' So pretty clearly again, advantage John.
..
|
You said you weren't measuring solely by playoff wins, yet that's exactly what you're doing.
If their stats and individual accomplishments were similar, then having one more Lombardi could be a tiebreaker. But they're not close. Postseason stats aren't close either. Pretty disingenuous stuff.
Before Mahomes came along, I thought Rodgers was the most talented QB I'd ever seen. And I've heard unbiased analysts make the case that they're 1 and 2 in terms of talent. Objectively, it's hard to say that Elway has Rodgers beat in any way other than arm strength.