[RaidersOftheCellar]

Originally Posted by BroncoBuff

Elway's stats definitely take some of the luster off Elway's career, but check this out:


Everybody knows Aaron Rodgers career stats are better than Elway's - significantly better in most every category: Comp.%, yards, TD passes, Ints, on and on. Yet it happens their career W-L records (reg season, updated this week) records are virtually identical:

Rodgers 150-83-1
Elway .. .148-82-1

15 starter yrs, Elway 10 Playoff apps
15 starter yrs, Rodgers 11 Playoff apps


PLAYOFF RECORDS
(each started 21 playoff games)

J.Elway ...14-7 ~ 5-1 Ch.Gs ~ 2-3 Super Bowls
Rodgers 11-10 ~ 1-4 Ch.Gs ~ 1-0 Super Bowls

Do the math:
Elway suffered 3 WC + Div playoff losses
Rodgers suffered 6 WC + Div playoff losses

Now. Making your Top 10 All-time lists ... who's the better Quarterback?

.

Rodgers. Next question.