Quote:
Originally Posted by staylor26
This logic is flawed.
A WR1 is still more "valuable" than a WR2 that can play RB too.
I think so many of you are missing this aspect of team building and roster construction. It's not debatable, Aiyuk is 100% their WR1, and you don't choose your WR2 over your WR1 all things even. If Deebo is the significantly cheaper option, then that's a reason, but not "versatility".
|
I agree Debo will come cheaper than Aiyuk and that’s one of the reasons I think SF if they have to choose, will keep Debo.
I think this is a good discussion, but it’s a little unclear what we’re debating.
I think there’s a general consensus. Debo is more important.
I think there’s a general consensus Aiyuk is a better WR, but if Debo ever has a season like he has several years ago, that would be a hard argument to sustain.
There are split views on who they would choose to keep if they have to make that choice.
And then there are different perspectives on what the word “value “means. But I think that’s too subjective to really matter.
To me the key issue is, who will they choose if they have to choose. And I think the split views will continue on that. And clearly it’s a very hard choice. Both of them are great players and key components of the San Francisco offense.