To save everybody time and words, here's now if works
A: We could have gotten this receiver, he's doing good on his current team
B: No, he wouldn't have worked here for this reason ____. What he's currently doing wouldn't translate to the Chiefs.
A: Ok this other receiver is also doing well on his team, we should have gotten him
B: No, clearly he wouldn't have done well here because of this reason ____....
A: Oh well, how about this other receiver, he's not doing great on his team but I think he would have been good for us
B:
You wanted him? Look at what he's doing on his current team! And you wanted him?!? Clearly this means you didn't appreciate us winning the Superbowl last year and that you think we can't win the Superbowl this year and you're not a true fan!