Manning is pretty much consensus top 3, I’d have to imagine. If I had to guess the average top 5, most people’s top 3 would probably be locked in:
1. Brady
2. Montana
3. Manning
Then you’ve probably got some hodgepodge of Steve Young, Favre, Rodgers, Brees, Unitas, Elway and Marino rounding out the top 10.
Mahomes has to be making these lists sweat a little bit. I don’t think he quite has the individual statistics to warrant putting him in the top 10 just yet, but when you start talking about impact, scorching the record books, accolades, wins, and Super Bowls, I don’t think I’d argue with putting him in the top 15. Already.
And when you start talking about peak, idk. He’s probably top 5 and I’m not sure we’ve seen his best ball just yet.
|