Quote:
Originally Posted by penguinz
You guys are waaaay too generous with your views on players.
No way you didn't grow up with participation trophies.
Elite should be reserved for the best of the best.
|
I don’t think it’s generous to consider Peyton elite even before he got any hardware. Brees and rodgers is a bit generous but I don’t see issues with calling them elite either. I don’t think it’s generous to consider Marino elite.
A Super Bowl appearance in year 2 is a hell of an accomplishment. And out of all the QBs out there he’s clearly separated himself from guys like Allen and Herbert. He’s a clear qb2 and just because he isn’t mahomes doesn’t mean he’s not elite