Quote:
Originally Posted by RunKC
I can see why everybody isn’t quick to anoint Pat. Tons of good QB’s started hot and came back to Earth over time.
RGIII, Watson, Dak and Carr were all proclaimed franchise QB’s after a small sample size and then crashed hard.
Mahomes isn’t going to crash with his talent, Andy Reid’s playcalling and the surrounding talent, but I get why they are bullish.
|
I've never thought any of those QB's looked like potential superstars...they looked like serviceable to above average starters. Luck is the only one, to me, that seemed to possess potential star qualities..and the Colts ****ed up his career trajectory ROYALLY.
I said early last year that Watson was living off the "throw it up for grabs" bombs... and it wasn't sustainable. Jury is still out on him...but I doubt he is ever an "elite" QB.
I dont think Goff will be anything more than above average...his long ball touch is terrible. Carr has been around long enough that we all have a pretty good idea of his ceiling...he's "very good" but doesn't have that intrinsic killer quality like Brady/Favre/Ben.
I haven't seen enough of Wentz to make an educated opinion...
I do think Mayfield has potential to be a star...and predicted Dorsey would take him #1. If Cleveland ever pulls it's head out of it own ass...Mahomes vs. Mayfield will make for some interesting games.