[Rain Man]

My rankings:

#1 - Saint George - It's not very big for the money, and it's in a pretty isolated city. But I really like the design and the details of this house, and I have a good impression of Saint George. The house location requires you to drive everywhere, which I'm not crazy about, but it's sure pretty.

#2 - Logan - I'm not generally a fan of the Mediterranean style, and the interior trim gives me the impression that it's more about style than quality. But nonetheless, the views are amazing and I like the exterior - check it out on google street view. Plus, you're reasonably close to a big metro area. However, it's not really in a walkable area.

#3 - Salt Lake City. If this house was in a more walkable neighborhood, it might be my #1. I like the interior design. But even though it's in a big city, it's not really near anything. Still a great house, though.

#4 - Provo. I really like the exterior, but the interior is pretty nondescript. I also can't figure out the neighborhood.

#5 - Castle Valley. The Moab area is amazing, but not enough to make up for the difference in housing. This house is relatively small and only so-so in design.