Andy Reid is a terrible head football coach
 

Andy Reid got depantsed in the Super Bowl by Bruce Arians.

Bruce ****ing Arians and Tom ****ing Brady.

Well, you see, Andy Reid is an offensive genius, and how dare we question Andy Reid's genius in not running the ball and not utilizing the screen pass in the face of an epically brutal pass rush, a patchwork offensive line and a QB with a hurt toe?

How dare we question his geniusness?
__________________

Oh, and Spags? The "great Brady Killer"? They had his defense figured out by the 2nd quarter and he couldn't adjust it. He was Bob Sutton Jr.

Remember that 49ers game last year? This is that game all over again.

Reid refused to run. Stupid playcalling cost us the game and it ended with a turnover.

I think hes a good head coach but a horrific play caller/game manager. . hes a good leader and good at building a team of guys who wnt to play for each other. .

he just needs to trust his coordinators. .

What about the Arizona game??

:banghead:

You can't be a good head coach and horrible game manager at the same time.

That's like saying 'he's a good driver, just keeps getting into accodents'

Milkman said it best. Andy is an elite HC Monday-Saturday and below average at best on Sunday's

It's the truth.

And ultimately, since Sunday is the ultimate barometer, Andy is a below average HC. AT BEST.

He's a pretty good coach except for three hours on Sunday.

Jamaal lost the game.

Yeah.

Matt Cassel graded out perfectly in practice, too...

that flea flicker attempt tho...

You said he threw the game on purpose and that Jamaal was in on it also.
So how do you also call him "bad" if he was trying to lose?

reid thinks smith is good enough, proof of how bad a coach he is

You shut your dirty whore mouth.

IT SHOULD HAVE NEVER BEEN THAT CLOSE.

Read the thread or get the **** out.

This is a thread for all those who know that Andy Reid is ****ing terrible.

Jamaal Charles is the most talented RB the Chiefs have ever had.

Not his fault his coach is a blithering idiot.

I hear ya. Deal is the Chiefs are a good team BUT they don't know how to win these types of games and, in the process, take the next step at becoming a consistently good team. A HUGE problem is that you rely on good coaching to get you over the hump and to the next level. In KC the in-game coaching decisions are what is preventing the Chiefs from taking the next step in becoming a consistently good team. Last night, all of Reids shortcomings as a game day coach were on display for all to see. He failed and so did the Chiefs as a result. :shake:

This is what Philly fans watched for a decade? Andy is lucky he never caught a battery snowball himself.

That's kind of my point, dipshit.

How does he have a job, STILL, after constant gross incompetence??

Either he threw the game and ownership knows about it and it's all good, or Reid is a terrible coach and Clark is a terrible owner and we will never win a Super Bowl as long as the Hunt family owns the team...

A big old shit Sammich either way.

Pick one.

He's not a HC based on merit, that's for ****ing sure.

Anyone on this board except you, 'Zilla, KC native and the dipshit who posted that 'Jamaal lost the game' could have called a better game than Reid.

...and Kubiak is just as bad. Wow what a shitshow last night was.

Spot the **** on.

Since ownership is cool with Reid being incompetent, we just have to assume that's the way they like things to be ran.

And that this is the way it's gonna be.

Or its all rigged and that's why Andy throws the games away.

Pick one.

ROFL I'd add Zilla to that list. ;)

I'll edit him in.

yep Andy was carried by two Hall of Famers, TO and Dawkins on both sides of the ball to his lone Super Bowl

Andy and McNabb played defense against them the same way Andy/Alex are playing defense against Houston/Charles/Maclin

BUT it SAYS A LOT when you get OUT-COACHED by one Gary F***ING Kubiak! :doh!:

I'm over it.

Won't be watching much football this weekend, but it sucks that we have to wait until next Monday night to try and recover.

The WORST.

That had to be the biggest collective combination of talented players and shit coaches on one field at one time this year.

Wasn't reid just following orders from the league office? Get your story straight.

It's like they had a bet between them, who could do the most dumb shit while still keeping the score close.

The fighting, the undisciplined penalties.

Thursday Night Meltdown.


It was embarrassing.

You tell me :

Does Reid suck, and the front office sucks by proxy and we will never win a Super Bowl because below average is a-okay??

OR

Does Reid throw these games away on purpose??

There has to be a REASON he's allowed to draw a paycheck and call himself an NFL head football coach. It's certainly not his stellar Sunday performances over the years...

You tell me what you think it is.

Kubiak was well on his way to losing that game until their QB fired him in halfway through it

Seems to be a terrible in game coach, but great in every other aspect. Not sure if that's an endorsement, though

Matt Cassel graded out perfectly in practice too.

As well all know, Tuesday - Saturday means squat if you shit the bed damn near every Sunday.

Yup

Probably because despite his ****ups he wins more games than he loses (.587).

I want to add I am not defending him I never wanted him hired in the first place.

He has a winning record in KC ... Not sure how that's damn near every Sunday, but I'm not here to argue today.

It certainly doesn't allay my fears.

Look, at the most crucial moments in the game last night, he routinely made bad decisions. The best one, offensively, was bringing Knile Davis in the game in the 4th qtr score and lining up in what looked to be a pass formation. That play was ****ing money. Beyond that, it was a series of aborted fetuses when we needed a Coach with his experience to make the appropriate calls. Disappointing to say the least....

He's a coach who wins more than he loses. He's a safe pick, that's why he'll have a job as long as he wants one.

The reason Andy won in Philly was three fold.

1) Philly's D was excellent and had a nasty mindset. Our defense is good but doesn't seem to have the mindset to crush a good offenses spirit.

2) McNabb was a much better QB then Smith. In fact Smith has more talent at the offensive talent positions then McNabb had. Remember, the Eagle trotted out Freddie Mitchell for multiple seasons.

3) At the time Andy's horizontal passing attack was innovative. It isn't anymore.

Because you can get a winning record in KC beating up on the likes of playing Oak and SD twice a year, plus we get Buf, Jax, Houston, etc on our schedule often.

Anytime we come up against a real playoff caliber opponent (SF, Den, Arizona, etc.) We come out and shit the bed.

He beats the teams he should beat. But never takes the next step.

Todd Haley had a winning record in KC, too...

Kinda, that's all true, but...

Andy won in Philly because of Jim Johnson's defense.

When Johnson died, so did Reid's domination of the NFC East.

The reason Reid NEVER took the next step, even with that stellar defense??

BECAUSE HE'S A TERRIBLE HEAD COACH.

I guess I dreamt beating New England, Seattle, and 4 other teams with winning records last year.

Bowles and McDermott were two DCs Andy had after Johnson and he underminded them both to fall on the sword for his mistakes and both of them currently field two of the better defenses in the NFL today.

19-26 isn't a winning record

19-26 in 3 seasons.

Yeah, I forgot about 2009.

It's those things that make you go :hmmm:

Take away games started by Tuel, Keenum, Campbell, Pryor etc and does this still hold up?

eventually we are going down a path of "would Dorsey fire his friend" if yes, who would he consider as replacements, assuming from that tree. If no, are Andy and Dorsey a package, do we have to fire both and start over. Dorsey has done his job, the question is how is the staff hierarchy considering we hired Andy before Dorsey.

This board loves Andrew Luck. Go take away all his wins against shit teams and report back

Those 3 fumbles were all on Andy Reid. Blame Andy!!!

What about his wins against shit playoff teams??

Read the thread.

SITUATIONAL FOOTBALL, MOTHER****ER - HAVE YOU HEARD OF IT??
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z...psirpt0lsv.jpg

Pfft. That's even more damning. What's that matter when you lose to Ten and Oak and miss the playoffs at 9-7??

That's indicitive of terrible coaching.

We have possibly the deepest roster from position to position in the league, the talent to beat ANY TEAM, including both Super Bowl participants from last year...

And you lose to doormats like Ten and Oak??

That's terrible coaching, by definition.

Primarily yes, but somewhat no. The top two picks he had in his first two drafts are turning out to be flops. His 1:1 pick could be historically bad, and the Dee Ford pick looks to be 1st rd back-up material. The right side of the OL is pathetic, and he owns that. I really like most of the moves he's made, but I just can't get over how bad half the OL looks.

No one is firing Reid. And he's also done nothing worthy of being fired. This is akin to drafting Derek Carr because he's a QB and we need a QB. We're not doing better than Reid. Firing a guy doesn't mean upgrade. We still couldn't have had anyone that was an upgrade to Alex Smith. If this board ran the Chiefs, we'd be more of a laughing stock than Jacksonville

Andy is just going to be Andy. As long as he's here - and he'll be here quite a while if he strings together .500+ football teams - we're going to have games like this.

Too smart for his own good! I've heard that about someone else on this team as well. What a pairing we have Chiefs fans, a QB and HC that are just TOO smart.

And that's supposed to be their bread and butter.

Andy was Oline and TEs as a position coach.

Has he ever been an OC (besides his own) at the NFL level??

Don't think so...

I'm talking about ingame management on Sunday gamedays.

You're the type of mother****er where someone asks you the time, you try to to tell them how to build a watch.

I'm no draftnik. I'm not a talent evaluator.

But I've played enough Madden and watched enough football to know that I could've done a better job than Reid last night.

And his in game incompetence is enough to get him fired, if I were the owner.

It was embarrassing and unacceptable.

I would DEMAND greatness.

Be great or be gone.

And Andy is far from great.

Reid is still better than most coaches in the league

as horrible as those picks are, and they are horrible. Dorsey has given us Marcus Peters, Mitch Morse, Travis Kelce. These are diamond in the rough picks Fat Scott could never pick for us. Fat Scott only gave us 4 good players cause they landed in his lap. Even though Dorsey misses he still does his homework in all phases and lands us good players with his bad ones. Fat Scott would only get us turds. Dorsey has found us Ron Parker, Jaye Howard, Hussain Abdullah, on the scrap heap. Fat Scott was giving us Stanford Routt, Sabby Piscitelli and Peyton Hillis. Horrible.

Sanka - get some.

That's a laughable ****ing excuse.

That means they're too ****ing stupid to do their jobs.

They're jocks. This is football.

If you over think yourself, then you aren't as smart as everyone think s you are.

That is a sad state of affairs if that's the truth.

Only because 80% of NFL owners are too scared to take a chance on an unproven coach.

Oh good grief. You've watched football and you've played madden. Wow

Bill Belichick should've been fired after MNF @ KC last year. Demand greatness

Obviously.

lol..this.

Apparently that's all anyone needs.

Reid has been a HC in the NFL for 16 years, and he's incompetent.

I can be incompetent too.

Still haven't answered my question -

How does Reid still have a job?

Is Reid a terrible coach, and ownership is okay with that

OR

Does he throw games on purpose??

You've avoided it twice now.

He's really more of a Monday-Wednesday-Friday coach.

He's truly special

Reid has been a HC in the NFL for 16 years, and he's incompetent.

How does Reid still have a job?

Is Reid a terrible coach, and ownership is okay with that

OR

Does he throw games on purpose??

It's not tough to figure that it's one or the other.

Andy Reid has proven that he can't gameplan when he only has 4 days in between games.

If the NFL is rigged, and Reid purposely throws games ... Isn't he doing his job?

I know.

Most Hulkamamiacs I knew growing up would rather light themselves on fire and jump out a window than admit that pro wrestling is rigged, too...

So, since your cognitive dissonance has kicked in and you can't fathom that Reid would EVER throw a game on purpose...

That leaves us with :

He's a terrible coach, ownership is cool with that, and not only will we never win a SB with Andy Reid as HC, but we most likely will never win a SB while the Hunts own this team.

In psychology, "cognitive dissonance" is the mental stress -or discomfort - experienced by an individual who holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas, or values at the same time, or is confronted by new information that conflicts with existing beliefs, ideas, or values.

In this scenario, the idea or belief that football isn't manipulated by refs and coaches to achieve a desired outcome for profit (be it commercials, Vegas/gambling, playoff seeding, etc) is conflicted by the evidence presented to you; your cognitive dissonance is created when you try to rationalize why Andy Reid is just a good coach who makes bad decisions or some such bullshit.

I'm telling you, factually, that in order to actually be a good coach, one consistently must put their team in positions to win.

Andy Reid does not.

LOGICALLY, this makes Andy Reid a bad coach, by definition.

Now, here we are, still engaging in cognitive dissonance, because you want to believe Andy is a good coach...despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary. It causes discomfort for you.

And you don't want believe the NFL is rigged, but that's a paradox in this situation , because if it's NOT rigged, that means Andy Reid IS not a good coach, and that ownership is not only okay with it, they're rolling in dough hand over fist.

Which logically leads us to conclude that Andy, Alex, Chunt, and the entire shitshow are here to stay...lather, rinse, repeat.

And who wants to believe that??

It's very discomforting.

So, a lot of folks use their cognitive dissonance to not deal with the harsh, ugly reality of football in Kansas City.

I think I know EXACTLY what it means, thanks.

That was on the house, btw.

;)

You're welcome.

Your leap in logic is quite fascinating

Lol, you are something else Rabble with this HOW DOES HE STILL HAVE A JOB?!? HERP A DERP. Well for starters his teams are in the playoff hunt nearly every year....

And then his win percentage is only behind Belichick, Mccarthy, Harbaugh, Tomlin, and Paytons.

Andy Reid will always have a HC job in the NFL for however long he wants...

Unless you're Jacksonville or the Raiders, EVERY TEAM is in the playoff hunt every year, you ****ing DOLT.

It's called 'parity', and if you've been watching the same league I have for the past 20 years, you know all about it, and you feel like a dipshit right about now.