I would say that I agree that he is a little overrated. He is definitely not a true old shut down corner. However, he makes a lot of good plays. Every now and then, he gets beaten and that's when you take notice. I think his All American status is more a reflection of the competition than his domination. Don't get me wrong. The guy is a stud and is very solid, but he is by no means a great CB. Seems to me that he is better suited as a zone CB. All that said, I do think he's good enough that he will play in the NFL next year or the year after.

Collins will probally come out cause of the attention he has gotten.......

But given another year, he will be a man amongst boys, a beast and a quality LT.

If KC could get him cheap this year and teach him the NFL ? :)

Coffman got snubbed.

He was snubbed. The AP was snoozing.

Orange Cameltoe is generally an idiot, but Andre Smith is a stud and already one of the best linemen in the country.

kstater and Zach got PWNED! ROFL

Hence why he can't even beat out Paris Lenon on one of the worst defenses in the league.

Major reach by the Lions ... as usual.

Vindication is sweet. Zach and kskater are my bitches. ROFL

I remember when I used to get drunk and high and watched porno, I thought I was bad ass. Then I got sober.

You've been here less than a month. Are you a dupe account or what?

I believe he is orange cameltoe. He nailed the prediction.

Congratulations on being named a finalist? :shrug:

I don't see how I got PWNED though. Unless they retroactively named him to last years all-American list.

how exactly did you own them? Andre Smith has yet to win the Outland or be named All-American.

Now, he may very well be given both, but he hasn't yet.

And I don't see anyone in this thread arguing he wasn't a good player, just that he wasn't a 2007 AA.

You're a complete and utter ****ing idiot.

And you will be banned again in 5, 4, 3........

Gino Torretta won the 1992 Heisman over Marshall Faulk. The people know who the better player was.

Just because Andre Smith didn't earn All-American honors in 2007 that doesn't mean Kirk Barton had a superior season.

There is so much politics involved in college football that I can't believe fans take these honors and awards to heart like they are undisputable accolades.

oops ROFL