I would not trade Edman. I doubt Gorman starts the season in the majors, and he’s the likely DH anyway.

I thought Gorman was supposed to have a good glove?

Why would you want to get rid of two starters for one possible starter? Who is going to start at the other position? Who is going to be quality depth for those positions?
Hopefully Carpenter will be GONE after this season.

He’s not Allen Craig, but average is probably his ceiling at anywhere but maybe 1st.

Well I guess they got the WC so just decided to take the night off. 17 games was enough.

Carpenter starting again today and just cost the Cards a run because he couldn't drive in a runner at 3rd with 1 out. I ****ing despise that piece of shit and at this point I cant give Schildt any level of credit for the win streak given he is still ****ing dumb enough to run Carpenter out there under any circumstances.

So someone PM’d me on Facebook and asked how I felt about the Dewitt’s maybe selling the Cardinals? Holy shit couldn’t get to Google fast enough….. but it was just old ass Shannon having a senior moment. :shake:

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">&quot;There is absolutely no truth to that comment. Whatsoever,&quot; president Bill DeWitt III tells me about statement on radio broadcast that suggested the family as looking to sell <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/Cardinals?src=hash&amp;ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#Cardinals</a>.</p>&mdash; Derrick S. Goold (@dgoold) <a href="https://twitter.com/dgoold/status/1443669960589512713?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">September 30, 2021</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Carlson almost single handedly won the game yesterday. If they can keep performing like this at all levels who knows, 2011 may happen again.

He's got a good glove. He's struggle at times but it is his rookie year. He's not going to ever be Pujols level obviously but he will be a good piece you need on any playoff team. .265-.270/15-20/80-85 every year. Plus on the verge of a gold glove. :clap:

On a separate subject..........
I don't understand switching hitting in todays game. If your hitting .235/4/25 from one side and hitting .285/14/55 from the other. What's the advantage of hitting from the other side?

What teams have quality backups? This is baseball. Your good and not starting, you go to another team.

As for our team we are never having anything but at best, AAAA players as backup. Our starters go down, we take a hit, We cant change that.

I'm thinking we have a 3 year window starting next year before Flaherty's rookie deal is up. He's going to get big money from LA to go home. Dont want to waste a year.

WHEEEEEW!!!

Wainwright coming back for one more year. I see no problems with a one year commitment and he was our most reliable SP this year. We need all depth next year if this year was any indication.

Good news on Wano for one more year. Best year he has put together since 2014 and there may be a decent chance of holding up into his 40s with his command on the breaking stuff and not relying on power.

DeJong isn't a starting caliber big league SS. Hasn't been in 4 years.

I think far too many people forget how long its been since Paulie D showed the potential that made us think he could develop into anything more than a mistake hitter. 2017 is a long time ago - that guy's gone. He's not coming back.

PDJ is, at best, a solid bench hitter and nothing more. Edman is absolutely a Chris Taylor sort of Super Utility player in a perfect world. He's a very good defender but unless you're going to bat him 8th, I just don't see a good offensive spot for him. He's not a leadoff hitter - he doesn't have the plate discipline for it. He's going to live and die on his BABIP and those guys through massive cold spells.

If you have to start him, so be it. But he's not a guy you can start at SS defensively. Nor will he take an OF role from any of our regular 3. So that means he's at 2b, where Gorman presents a FAR higher upside over any meaningful timeline.

Then you go into FA to replace DeJong at SS. If you strike out, well at least Sosa will make more contact than PDJ and he's a better defender as well.

But really, the kind of deal you look for isn't combining the two - there aren't many teams looking to completely re-do their MI.

But if you could get the Reds to talk, a Paul DeJong for Sonny Gray trade makes a lot of sense for both sides. Or maybe someone like PDJ for Caleb Smith in the hopes of rehabbing Smith's value.

Team needs arms and the system is unusually bereft of them. It can't hurt to make some phonecalls.

Scherzer has faced the Cardinals twice this season, once with Washington and once with the Dodgers. He has allowed 10 hits and no earned runs in 14 innings, striking out 2.

How’s everyone feeling about tonight? Going to be tough to beat Scherzer if he’s on his game.