ChiefsPlanet

ChiefsPlanet (https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/index.php)
-   Nzoner's Game Room (https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/forumdisplay.php?f=1)
-   -   Chiefs 2024 Draft - trade multiple picks to Cardinals to get Marvin Harrison Jr. (https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/showthread.php?t=351050)

Woogieman 11-22-2023 09:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris Meck (Post 17238165)
Looks like there's a few of those in this draft, too.

People need to understand, though-you're not going to replace Travis Kelce on a one-for-one basis.

there's nothing wrong with Noah Gray other than he's not Travis Kelce and he plays on a team with him.

agree...you do have to find a Bell replacement though. Someone that is either a very good blocker, or that has high football IQ that isn't afraid to make a few tough catches each game until they have the luxury of targeting a guy in the 1st rnd within a few yrs. I like Gray, but without a true #1 WR, they will struggle a bit on 3rd and in the Red Zone.

Gravedigger 11-22-2023 09:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Woogieman (Post 17238120)
...and if Harrison tears an achilles, you have blown an entire draft- no Bolton, Humphrey, Gray, Karlaftis, Cook, Watson, Pacheco, Rice. Terrible idea, and who wants multiple picks at the bottom of the board when some rummy franchise will offer them multiple picks in the middle or near the top?

... and if Harrison and Mahomes end up being the next great QB WR duo in NFL history, you have succeeded multiple entire drafts. If you don't think that Noah Gray, Rashee Rice and Isaiah Pacheco are re-creatable then I can't help you. Eventually, just like with Mahomes, you need to take a risk.

Woogieman 11-22-2023 09:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gravedigger (Post 17238171)
Just that easy huh? 4 picks out of 260, 5-10 of those you own in that 260. Brett Veach has shown you he doesn't take good WR's, this organization has shown you they don't take good WR's, until it happens you can shit in one hand and hope in the other and see which fills up faster.

lol...no, it's not easy. Only a handful of orgs do it on a fairly consistent basis, the Chiefs being about as good as any. The point is, it can be done...of course they are the exception, but that's life when you host the AFC Champiosnhip every year. When you draft at the bottom, you can't trade the whole draft for one guy...(A) there are better trade partners than you (B) you only have 5 picks (so far), you're better off trading down a few and acquiring more picks so you can find a Puka Nacua (the current #6).

Special_K 11-22-2023 09:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris Meck (Post 17238128)
Legette is a 5th year senior who did literally nothing his first four years. This gives me great pause.

Mitchell, Franklin I like. Worthy, too. All different physical types, all can fly.

I’m not saying we draft Legette in the first. All I’m saying is any other years he’s first round talent but is likely there for us in the late 1st/2nd if we want him.

I’ve seen mocks where Worthy is taken by us picking 31/32. Any other year he’s gone top 20.

There’s just so many talented receivers in this class with real first round grades on guys that end up being taken in the 2nd. That and there’s a plethora of talented QBs coming out that teams will be spending early round picks on.

Woogieman 11-22-2023 09:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gravedigger (Post 17238180)
... and if Harrison and Mahomes end up being the next great QB WR duo in NFL history, you have succeeded multiple entire drafts. If you don't think that Noah Gray, Rashee Rice and Isaiah Pacheco are re-creatable then I can't help you. Eventually, just like with Mahomes, you need to take a risk.

That would be a great, hall of fame, record setting combo, no doubt, but how's the rest of the team? Dick Vermeil's defenses? It's hard to find that perfect balance in the cap era, I get it. I just think the biggest flaw is assuming a team drafting at 2 or 3 is going to trade with a team drafting at 28-32, even if its 5 picks...I think they will have a better value offer from one of many franchises that have desperately selected an iffy QB (NE, GB, Carolina, Pitt, Tenn, NYG) but think a WR will solve the prob.

Chris Meck 11-22-2023 09:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gravedigger (Post 17238180)
... and if Harrison and Mahomes end up being the next great QB WR duo in NFL history, you have succeeded multiple entire drafts. If you don't think that Noah Gray, Rashee Rice and Isaiah Pacheco are re-creatable then I can't help you. Eventually, just like with Mahomes, you need to take a risk.

No. You don't go full Ricky Williams, and that's about what it would take. You absolutely don't do that when you have a championship caliber football team at every other position group but half of your defense is up for a new contract and you're low on cap space.

Woogieman 11-22-2023 09:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Special_K (Post 17238191)
I’m not saying we draft Legette in the first. All I’m saying is any other years he’s first round talent but is likely there for us in the late 1st/2nd if we want him.

I’ve seen mocks where Worthy is taken by us picking 31/32. Any other year he’s gone top 20.

There’s just so many talented receivers in this class with real first round grades on guys that end up being taken in the 2nd. That and there’s a plethora of talented QBs coming out that teams will be spending early round picks on.

Exactly what I'm hoping...some team will be desperate for a QB even at 28-32, that they will trade down a few spots and pick up a 2nd or strong 3rd...Franklin, Polk, Egbuka, Legette, Mitchell/Worthy, and maybe a few emerging names will still be available.

Chris Meck 11-22-2023 09:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Special_K (Post 17238191)
I’m not saying we draft Legette in the first. All I’m saying is any other years he’s first round talent but is likely there for us in the late 1st/2nd if we want him.

I’ve seen mocks where Worthy is taken by us picking 31/32. Any other year he’s gone top 20.

There’s just so many talented receivers in this class with real first round grades on guys that end up being taken in the 2nd. That and there’s a plethora of talented QBs coming out that teams will be spending early round picks on.

I like either of the Texas guys. I worry a little about Worthy as an outside receiver in the NFL just because I don't know how he'll do against press-man being smaller. He can fly, though. But I'd rather not HAVE to manufacture clean releases for him.

Gary Cooper 11-22-2023 09:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr. tegu (Post 17238095)
So basically neither one will be even on our radar.

Yep. Andy likes his WRs with slimmer hips.

Chris Meck 11-22-2023 09:46 AM

Legette just gives me the heeby-jeebies.

Zero production for four years and then explodes as a 5th year senior? With that size and speed? Something ain't right there. I really don't think I'd spend a premium pick for him.

Special_K 11-22-2023 09:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris Meck (Post 17238209)
I like either of the Texas guys. I worry a little about Worthy as an outside receiver in the NFL just because I don't know how he'll do against press-man being smaller. He can fly, though. But I'd rather not HAVE to manufacture clean releases for him.

I’m a Kansas State fan as well and Mitchell carved up our secondary for nearly 150 yards and going against a corner who I think will get a look at the NFL. He’s tall but physical for his frame, has great downfield catching ability, and like I said, runs like a gazelle.

He would come in and easily be the best WR on this roster, which I know isn’t saying much.

OKchiefs 11-22-2023 10:02 AM

Too high to trade up - if you're going to trade up go up and get someone like Odunze in the teens

Special_K 11-22-2023 10:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris Meck (Post 17238213)
Legette just gives me the heeby-jeebies.

Zero production for four years and then explodes as a 5th year senior? With that size and speed? Something ain't right there. I really don't think I'd spend a premium pick for him.

I’m not saying we spend our first on him but his production this year is very impressive, and if he indeed runs a 4.3 at the combine with that 6’3” 227 Ibs frame he will be tough for teams to pass on.

DK Metcalf never had a season in college going over 650 yards. In fact, his senior numbers dropped off some from his junior year.

Again, not saying we spend that pick on him but we’ll have some options in the late 1st/2nd if we want him or some others in this class.

Chris Meck 11-22-2023 10:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Special_K (Post 17238253)
I’m not saying we spend our first on him but his production this year is very impressive, and if he indeed runs a 4.3 at the combine with that 6’3” 227 Ibs frame he will be tough for teams to pass on.

DK Metcalf never had a season in college going over 650 yards. In fact, his senior numbers dropped off some from his junior year.

Again, not saying we spend that pick on him but we’ll have some options in the late 1st/2nd if we want him or some others in this class.

I agree we'll have a shot at a talented WR, I'm just not sure I want to take a shot on that one.

Mitchell, Worthy, Franklin are my early guys I like so far, but I've not really been diving deep.

O.city 11-22-2023 10:17 AM

Trade that first to the 9ers for Aiyuk and be done with it.

Strongside 11-22-2023 10:20 AM

We would have to give up far too much for Harrison Jr. to be an option.

Keon Coleman and Malik Nabers, though? Absolutely.

I think the great news is that this year's WR class is far stronger than it has been in the past several years from top to bottom.

If I'm the Chiefs, I'm doing whatever I can to get into a slot where Nabers or Coleman are on the board. They aren't Harrison Jr, but they're still slam dunks IMO.

RealSNR 11-22-2023 10:20 AM

Time to start planting drugs on his ass.

People seemed to be grossed out by that Will Levis mayonnaise in coffee thing, too. Maybe float some rumors out there? He likes mustard in his diet coke?

Couch-Potato 11-22-2023 11:34 AM

Good news is that this is a really really strong WR class, we're discussing them on the draft sub-forum here:https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/showthre...350534&page=13

Monticore 11-22-2023 01:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 17238260)
Trade that first to the 9ers for Aiyuk and be done with it.

Cost is the issue there.

Megatron96 11-22-2023 02:01 PM

Can't trade multiple picks to get Harrison Jr., as great as that sounds.



Pivot: what's the deal with Brenden Rice? Runs a 4.38, a 10.7sec 100, 6'3", 205-lbs. Passer Rating of 127 when targeted.

Projected to go in the 3rd?

Always been a fan of his dad, so I've watched him a little bit. Looks a lot like his dad on the field.

BigRedChief 11-22-2023 02:10 PM

Giving up years of drafts for Harrison? That is whack.

Those draft picks are essential to us, way more than most teams. Mahomes is on a maxed out contract now. Other positions will need to be cheap.

Without those draft picks we have no chance to compete in coming years.

Icon 11-22-2023 02:12 PM

Malik Nabors at LSU is getting a lot of love for early first round but I think his team mate is not getting enough love. Brian Thomas is 6'4" 205 lbs and fast. For 2023 he has 55 receptions, 1,021 yards (18.6 yds/catch) and 14 TDs. I could see him getting into the back end of round one where we'll be picking. He could be a poor man's Marvin Harrison.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7cCP27uR9ds

RunKC 11-22-2023 02:13 PM

Rice and Toney are coming back next year bc they are cheap. As much as I don't like Skyy, he'll get the CEH treatment and be back. Also think Watson will return bc Mahomes trusts him, he's cheap and he's a good complimentary WR like he was last year.

I think Veach will solve this problem immediately in FA by getting a talented veteran WR. I wouldn't be surprised if he got a 2nd fairly priced vet WR like DJ Chark.

Then another WR in the first 2 rounds

FloridaMan88 11-22-2023 02:30 PM

Trading a fortune to draft Harrison, Jr. only to have him play on like 50% of the offensive snaps (see Rice’s usage).

Andy makes it almost impossible for rookie WR’s to have an immediate impact.

smithandrew051 11-22-2023 04:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RealSNR (Post 17238266)
Time to start planting drugs on his ass.

People seemed to be grossed out by that Will Levis mayonnaise in coffee thing, too. Maybe float some rumors out there? He likes mustard in his diet coke?

Billay told me that he plans to film and leak a sex tape with him.

I told him that was a hell of commitment to tank Harrison’s draft stock.

Billay replied, “Draft stock?”.

Skyy God 11-22-2023 04:19 PM

Never go full Balto.

Pinchshot 11-22-2023 04:19 PM

Chris Jones and a #1 to jump up. You either get a stud or you better draft 3 WRs and hope you have an A, B and C WR once done.

Rainbarrel 11-22-2023 04:28 PM

The Chiefs have an abysmal record of drafting a WR. So logic says bundle multiple picks together to draft one. Logic escapes me

sedated 11-22-2023 04:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Why Not? (Post 17237638)
It would take that or what the Vikings gave up to get Herschel Walker type of a deal. Problem is, neither of those teams (Vikings/Saints) won championships due to those deals so they are remembered in a negative light, even though Ricky was a good player. Can't remember if Walker was worth a shit for the Vikings or not.

That trade won the Cowboys multiple super bowls.

I had to look up the Ricky Williams trade and might have won the other team a title too if it weren't Washington. Washington did get Champ Bailey out of it but traded him for Clinton Portis. They also got LaVar Arrington, but used the rest of the picks on guys like Cade McNown, DWayne Bates, and Lloyd Harrison.

ArrowHeader 11-22-2023 05:40 PM

Throw in a couple more picks and have multi trade getting Justin Jefferson and Watt too

Chief Roundup 11-22-2023 05:56 PM

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/VK1jCWGHmgQ?si=gLNewj0MpoAHINDO" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; web-share" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Chiefshrink 11-22-2023 07:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bump (Post 17237622)
There's no way they would trade down that far and pass up on what appears to be a real generational talent at WR. They already are invested in Murray so they probably want Harrison JR and I wouldn't be surprised if he's picked #1 overall.

You'd probably have to give up damn near your entire draft and the next 2 years 1st round picks or something ridiculous and that isn't going to happen.

Murray is a crybaby who refuses to be a student of the game and Harrison will get neutered because of that I am afraid.

ChiefsFanatic 11-23-2023 01:53 AM

I swear, most of CP wants to treat Mahomes like Green Bay treated Rodgers.

If Marvin Harrison Jr. goes to a team with even a mediocre QB, he will be better in 5 years than any combination of players we draft in the first two rounds of the next 3 drafts.

Superstar Wide Receiver vs a handful of potential draft busts/booms. It's not a hard choice.

TwistedChief 11-23-2023 02:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChiefsFanatic (Post 17238988)
I swear, most of CP wants to treat Mahomes like Green Bay treated Rodgers.

If Marvin Harrison Jr. goes to a team with even a mediocre QB, he will be better in 5 years than any combination of players we draft in the first two rounds of the next 3 drafts.

Superstar Wide Receiver vs a handful of potential draft busts/booms. It's not a hard choice.

Yup, there's either trading at least 3 1's and 2 2's to move up in the draft and get Harrison OR there's not surrounding Mahomes with any weapons like GB did with Rodgers. There is no middle ground at all. Nice to have that cleared up.

scho63 11-23-2023 08:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TwistedChief (Post 17238989)
Yup, there's either trading at least 3 1's and 2 2's to move up in the draft and get Harrison OR there's not surrounding Mahomes with any weapons like GB did with Rodgers. There is no middle ground at all. Nice to have that cleared up.

You're being silly in what a team would have to give up.

Chief Roundup 11-23-2023 08:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChiefsFanatic (Post 17238988)
I swear, most of CP wants to treat Mahomes like Green Bay treated Rodgers.

If Marvin Harrison Jr. goes to a team with even a mediocre QB, he will be better in 5 years than any combination of players we draft in the first two rounds of the next 3 drafts.

Superstar Wide Receiver vs a handful of potential draft busts/booms. It's not a hard choice.

Right, because Karlaftis, McDuffie, Cook, FAU, and Rice haven't helped the team at all. Moore is not doing well but still, that is a lot of talent with those picks. We did not pick a player in the 1st in 2021 but we drafted Bolton and Creed with the two 2cd rounders we did have.
Yeah, it would be a good decision to give up all or most of those players for one WR.

Nightfyre 11-23-2023 08:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by scho63 (Post 17239672)
You're being silly in what a team would have to give up.

Not really. Moving up to a top 5 pick from 30+ is going to take more capital than we even have on the table. For reference, in 2021 the 49ers traded up from 12 to 3 and gave up three firsts and a third. It would be absurd.

smithandrew051 11-23-2023 08:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nightfyre (Post 17239681)
Not really. Moving up to a top 5 pick from 30+ is going to take more capital than we even have on the table. For reference, in 2021 the 49ers traded up from 12 to 3 and gave up three firsts and a third. It would be absurd.

Correct. Moving up from the end of the first to the beginning of the first would cost a ridiculous amount of picks.

The Panthers moved from 9 to 1, and it cost them 2 firsts, 2 seconds, and DJ Moore.

And those are the Panthers’ picks, which are far more valuable than the Chiefs’ picks.

scho63 11-23-2023 08:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nightfyre (Post 17239681)
Not really. Moving up to a top 5 pick from 30+ is going to take more capital than we even have on the table. For reference, in 2021 the 49ers traded up from 12 to 3 and gave up three firsts and a third. It would be absurd.

I would never give that much up so yeah, I would not do it for that. I want talent but not risky souch you can't recover for years.

Special_K 11-23-2023 10:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChiefsFanatic (Post 17238988)
I swear, most of CP wants to treat Mahomes like Green Bay treated Rodgers.

If Marvin Harrison Jr. goes to a team with even a mediocre QB, he will be better in 5 years than any combination of players we draft in the first two rounds of the next 3 drafts.

Superstar Wide Receiver vs a handful of potential draft busts/booms. It's not a hard choice.

Harrison is very good but nothing is guaranteed. As mentioned previously, this is a loaded WR class, and I think there’s guys in this draft class that will ultimately prove to be better than him when all is said and done.

The most aggressive move would be using our first 2 picks at WR without fleecing the farm. If we do that we still likely get what would be top 20 value at WR even in the 2nd given how deep this class is.

tk13 11-23-2023 10:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChiefsFanatic (Post 17238988)
I swear, most of CP wants to treat Mahomes like Green Bay treated Rodgers.

If Marvin Harrison Jr. goes to a team with even a mediocre QB, he will be better in 5 years than any combination of players we draft in the first two rounds of the next 3 drafts.

Superstar Wide Receiver vs a handful of potential draft busts/booms. It's not a hard choice.

We've already done more than GB did with Rodgers because we've given Mahomes some high round offensive weapons. CEH, Toney, Rice, Skyy. But even then, if you draft well Harrison will not be better than any combo of players you draft with multiple picks. There are always WRs and TEs who are successful in rounds 2, 3, 4. You just have to pick them.

kccrow 11-23-2023 10:45 PM

I really don't think you'd need to move up this year for a WR to be honest. Should be a couple of quality guys right there at 32.

TwistedChief 11-24-2023 12:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by scho63 (Post 17239672)
You're being silly in what a team would have to give up.

Walk me through the math that a team projected at 32 needs to do to move up to 3 in a draft heavy on QBs.

scho63 11-24-2023 06:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TwistedChief (Post 17239784)
Walk me through the math that a team projected at 32 needs to do to move up to 3 in a draft heavy on QBs.

Because we ain't moving up for a QB.

Who was the last team and year to give up exactly what you stated in the draft to move up?

TwistedChief 11-24-2023 06:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by scho63 (Post 17239809)
Because we ain't moving up for a QB.

Who was the last team and year to give up exactly what you stated in the draft to move up?

Exactly what I stated?

The 49ers traded 3 1’s and a 3 the following year to move from 12 to 3.

Go look at the standard JJ draft value chart. If we were just dealing with this year’s picks, it would need to be at least 3 1’s and 2 2’s. And those picks in future years will be discounted.

No, we’re not moving up for a QB, but in a draft where a premium position like QB is highlighted at the top, all of those top picks are worth more.

You’re tremendously off base here.

The Franchise 11-24-2023 10:29 AM

Arguing with scho about the draft is pointless. He knows dick about it.

scho63 11-24-2023 02:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Franchise (Post 17239931)
Arguing with scho about the draft is pointless. He knows dick about it.

Well you do know about dick so good advice.

MahomesMagic 11-24-2023 02:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tk13 (Post 17239765)
We've already done more than GB did with Rodgers because we've given Mahomes some high round offensive weapons. CEH, Toney, Rice, Skyy. But even then, if you draft well Harrison will not be better than any combo of players you draft with multiple picks. There are always WRs and TEs who are successful in rounds 2, 3, 4. You just have to pick them.


Weapons.

ROFL

MarkDavis'Haircut 11-24-2023 06:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by scho63 (Post 17240184)
Well you do know about dick so good advice.

ROFL

Justman59 11-24-2023 06:30 PM

How much will it take to move up and take the kid from South Carolina?

Veach should look at Legette. He can do everything our receivers can't. Legette can get open, outrun defenders, leap for contested balls, jet sweeps, and my favorite "hold on to the ball."

Chris Meck 11-25-2023 08:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Justman59 (Post 17240583)
How much will it take to move up and take the kid from South Carolina?

Veach should look at Legette. He can do everything our receivers can't. Legette can get open, outrun defenders, leap for contested balls, jet sweeps, and my favorite "hold on to the ball."

Well, let me ask you this-

Why didn't he do literally anything at all for four years, and suddenly, as a fifth year senior is a world beater? Does that give you pause?

Because it gives me pause.

Coogs 11-25-2023 08:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris Meck (Post 17240926)
Well, let me ask you this-

Why didn't he do literally anything at all for four years, and suddenly, as a fifth year senior is a world beater? Does that give you pause?

Because it gives me pause.

I'm not on this bandwagon either. But SC did have a new OC this season. Their old one was the OC for the Huskers this year. :hmmm:

Chris Meck 11-25-2023 08:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coogs (Post 17240955)
I'm not on this bandwagon either. But SC did have a new OC this season. Their old one was the OC for the Huskers this year. :hmmm:

A one year wonder WR doesn't scare me if they're like...a junior. and/or at like Ohio State, where the roster is stacked.

But four years of nothing, and all the sudden, they're Megatron?

I don't know, man.

Coogs 11-25-2023 10:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris Meck (Post 17240957)
A one year wonder WR doesn't scare me if they're like...a junior. and/or at like Ohio State, where the roster is stacked.

But four years of nothing, and all the sudden, they're Megatron?

I don't know, man.

I'm not in on this guy either. I just made a poor attempt at some humor regarding the Huskers offense this season. :)

Couch-Potato 11-25-2023 10:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Justman59 (Post 17240583)
How much will it take to move up and take the kid from South Carolina?

Veach should look at Legette. He can do everything our receivers can't. Legette can get open, outrun defenders, leap for contested balls, jet sweeps, and my favorite "hold on to the ball."

I'm curious about this guy too, but we can prob get him where we're at.

Metcalf went #64, and I'm not sure anyone's saying this kids better than him just that they're similar.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:03 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.