![]() |
Quote:
They took both staley and davis in the first round, as well as Iupati... I don't think that's absurd in the least. |
Quote:
|
can't trade Albert, can't sign him. seems like a good candidate for riding two season on tag then bye
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
that's why the last action item in my scenario is "bye" :D
|
Quote:
|
fish was raw talent compared with Joeckel -- we covered this during pre draft threads. the staff knows he's going to take time
especially playing the opposite side |
Quote:
|
Quote:
he is going to be fine. Its a transition. learning a new position, playing against a big big jump in competition. its all relative. |
Indianapolis gets 2 Franchise QB's for 25 years with their 1st picks.
The Chiefs get a project RT with their 1st pick. **** everything. |
I know we don't want to upset Albert, but there seems to be little chance he will be back next year.
I'm not sure why we shouldn't give Fisher time at LT and see if he does better over there. He's the future at LT anyway. Albert is just a rent a player, essentially |
Might as well. Already blew the top pick on him.
|
You are relentless. When things fit your agenda you are on top of it. Let me see you post something against the grain for you and I will read it.
|
Quote:
Too bad he had a really bad game. |
Remember when people were calling for moving Albert and playing Fisher at LT right away?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Indy has it down to an art form. We suck at sucking. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I don't see myself as a negative person in real life, but sometimes you read CP and make 5 or 6 posts and feel like you only said negative stuffs. Of course, it's far easier to be a naysayer on this board, because you go hard at the negative side and if you're right you're right, but if you're wrong you just get to say "I'm happy I was wrong" or "Sure, I run this player down all day and night, but I want him to be great". So you get to straddle the fence and celebrate victory no matter what happens, not a terrible position. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
BUT JUST GIVE IT TIME |
Quote:
It is what it is. It is easier to follow the herd's mentality than to formulate your own opinion and stand out from the crowd since so many people want to be right instead of hoping. I get that we will more than likely not do well this season, but it is ridiculous to be at the point the we have to be pissed that a rookie struggled in his 2nd preseason game, when the top of this draft was pretty barren in regard to top selections. /end rant Continue to rotate CP. |
Quote:
Boy, where have I heard that before. http://cdn1.sbnation.com/imported_as...allery_600.jpg |
He's young and has an injury he is dealing with. It's probably best to let him heal. You can't come to any conclusions in the 2nd preseason game. It will be mid season or late before you know what you got. And maybe even next year. It can 2 years for a young Tackle to adjust to the NFL. He has enormous talent, size and strength. Also athleticism. I think he will be fine.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
There's a steady distribution there. People have unreasonable expectations because our HC and GM got "their guys". They decided that for our future and that in order to win right now, Fisher and Alex Smith were the best available options. Time will tell, but they better be right because we just struggled through four years of insufferable pricks that thought they got "their guys". And I sure as **** want to see the best available NFL prospect look like it out of the gate. That's it. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
But it's not just one game. Reports were that he had not looked great during training camp and even the Saints game last week included Fisher getting bull rushed. The shocking thing is this has not even been against good competition. |
Quote:
And the people that are asking for some patience with Fisher are the same folks that absolutely crucify young players on other teams. If the 1st overall pick was playing like this for a rival, holy shit, that's all you'd hear about around here. |
Quote:
The gate, but it was even told to us that it was potential that made the selection not refinement. |
Quote:
I think naysaying is a good way to draw attention to yourself or to set up some kind of heads I win/tails you lose |
A couple more years of 1st and 2nd round offensive linemen will have this OLine clicking on all cylinders.
Traded for another QB that needs a century to make good decisions. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Adjustment period? He's the number 1 pick for Christ's sake and he has shown absolutely 0 potential. |
Quote:
I agree that the guy has to be nothing short of pro bowler, and he still won't live up to being 1.1. I get all that stuff. I'm not crazy about taking a RT at 1.1 either. I just can't stand the agendas that people are using a game this early in the preseason to drive an "I told you so" agenda. The kid deserves a reasonable amount of time to prove what he can do. The idea that he HAS to be a great player from the get-go... who really cares if he is? We're not winning the Super Bowl this year. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
So why did we take him number 1? |
Quote:
But we do have to understand he didn't play against top collegiate competition before, let alone NFL level competition. He's also not playing his natural position. I kind of feel like he should be playing LT now because he will be our LT of the future, Branden Albert's ego be damned. But you also are afraid of the "shades of Trezelle Jenkins" feeling, where Whitlock wrote that memorable column about how he hated the pick, and Gunther gave him this big spiel, showing him game film and saying how Tree's problems were all technique and they could coach him up. Who knows what'll happen... there's probably no use slicing each other up about it. I guess I don't understand why goatse feels the need to gloat when someone on our team goes out there and fails. Why take pleasure in that? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
We should be aiming for the post season and the Superbowl. That's what these moves were made for. |
Quote:
:facepalm: |
Quote:
But the idea that Fisher ends up being a shitty pick if he ends up as a pro bowler in year 2 or 3, but struggles in his first starts, is just plain ludicrous. Why is it so critical to be a star from game 1? |
Quote:
Do you think the recent SB winners give a **** about one of the best, if not the best, tackle playing for the Browns? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Im not calling him a bust by any means, but the dude has looked about as bad as any 1st round pick we've had, Tyson Jackson included.
|
Dorsey thought he had Albert sold off and was dead wrong. Now the line has the most talent I've seen in nearly a decade. They should perform like it.
|
Quote:
|
I seriously laugh my as of at anyone who assumes Albert is gone.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
The same people calling him a pussy for a possible injury are the same ones not speaking a word about guys like Geno and Mingo also being injured this preseason. The same people who (even if they didn't want to draft a RT) blasted picking Joeckl over Fisher because he was safer, are the same ones bitching that Fisher is less NFL-ready than Joeckl. If you want to evaluate Fisher play-by-play, great, let's have that discussion. But it's never going to be a discussion if there are people that set this unrealistic expectation that he has to be some star, injury-free player from the get-go, which everybody knew he was not going to be. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
**** that. I just want the guy to be good. Like right now. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I think that is the right thing to do with the #1 pick. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
But blocking PARYS ****ING HARALSON WOULD BE NICE DAMMIT. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
So how are the other top 4 picks of the 2013 draft doing? I ask, because those are the guys we need to be comparing Fisher to. His peers. Anyone know?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
We spent an entire offseason arguing this point and look....here we are again. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
But he struggles through the second preseason game and its abandon ****ing ship, because heaven ****ing forbid, you get called out on CP for being a homer. |
Quote:
Eric Fisher is almost the worst ranked OT on PFF right now. |
Quote:
Look, I want to take a chance on playmakers. Again, I'm not excited about the Fisher pick because of positional value. But I think Fisher will be an excellent Right Tackle and think it's silly to think his value is any less because he struggled early on, but became a great player in a reasonable amount of time. Even if Fisher becomes an elite Tackle, it's a terrible pick if Manuel or Geno become franchise QBs. That doesn't change regardless of how he plays early on. |
Quote:
A guy like Geno I don't care about because there was never any realistic option where he was gonna get picked top 10 by any team. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
It's embarrassing right now that we appear not to have gotten the best one. |
Quote:
I seem to remember few people wanting either. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
This is all yet to be played out by next season & all depends on how Albert and Fisher perform this season. Albert has yet to sign an extension so his future is undetermined. It's going be very discouraging if we take another OT in next years draft with our first pick. |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:29 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.