Putting this in here instead of in the first round mock thread...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tribal Warfare
(Post 16233344)
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/3YuioqgnAVc" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen></iframe>
High floor, try hard in Karlaftis not a gamewrecker which is what you trade up for like Wyatt who is a badass.
George doesn't play like Kerrigan if anything Hali was a Kerrigan clone.
Furthermore the way he rushes won't work as an NFL DE consistently unless he's the second coming of Reggie White or prime JJ Watt.
That's why I like Cam Thomas because he does play like a bigger Hali/Kerrigan
|
This was literally the worst game of his career because they wanted him to keep using a speed rush to the outside, which isn't the way he should be used, and you picked it as your end-all-be-all example of him being a terrible player? Don't cherry-pick a bad game. I can cherry-pick a shit show from every favorite on the list sans maybe Hutchinson's 2021 tape. I'm fine with you using it as an example of his weakness, but you should also be talking about his strengths and presenting that tape if you're going here.
Players that can power rush are absolutely the top rushers year-over-year in the NFL, not speed rushers. There are a few speedy standouts, but they are rare commodities. Ideally, you have a guy with power that can bend a bit better but it's hard to get it all in one package.
Do I wish Karlaftis could bend better? Yes. I think he can be taught a few things to help him out. The guys behind him though have much more significant overall issues in their games.
My next guy would be Sam Williams from a talent perspective but he has some power issues at this stage. I love his potential, but he has to get stronger and develop much more of a power rush for the NFL and he has to set the edge against the run much better (like most coming from college).
Cam Thomas is virtually the same guy as Karlaftis. I like him a lot but very much the same issues and less developed hand play.
Ebiketie doesn't really fit a 4-3 very well. I see him as a 3-4 OLB. He's a guy I like a ton but I do worry about his ability to set the edge in the NFL in an even front.
Mafe is kind of in that group of guys without a lot of bend but I think he has more than Karlaftis and Thomas. That said I don't think he comes with the same power. He's a nice player but very, very inconsistent. I don't like his production overall. If you can get him to be consistent he could turn out to be a better pro. I don't like his age but its' not a complete deal-breaker. I'd be fine with him as the pick, but he comes with some significant bust potential in my eyes.
After this group, I think there's a very big drop-off again either in athleticism or development and I'm really not about to talk about them this early.