Buehler445 |
01-18-2017 08:53 AM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spider2YBanana
(Post 12694854)
This is the best strategy considering the wealth of picks we have, the overall strength of the roster (we can afford to trade a 1st) and the depth and top-end talent that will be coming out in 2018.
Sam Darnold, USC Every QB from USC has largely sucked ass
Josh Rosen, UCLA Hasn't won anything.
Lamar Jackson, Louisville Can't throw
Josh Allen, Wyoming Small school. Other than Wentz and Romo never pan out.
Mason Rudolph, OKState spread QB. Meh arm
Jake Browning, Washington Got truly exposed against real defense
There's a lot to like there. You might have a Manning-Rivers-Roethlisberger situation out of that group.
And as an added bonus, ditching Smith's $20M cap hit in 2018 and replacing it with a rookie QB contract will allow you to spend more money on the re-ups that will be due players going into their second contracts. God knows what Peters is going to want.
|
It's not like that group is without questions too. And I haven't even watched those guys virtually at all. They can't interview those guys until they declare. IMO that's the biggest part. Yeah. You have to see some tools and mental acuity on film, but if they interview like Geno then piling resources to go get a guy you know nothing about is rough.
Then if you end up with a bunch of picks and can't get the move done for a QB - presuming your guy is there - then you are stuck with picks and spending those resources on lower impact players.
That strategy carries a lot of risk. If there is a guy you think you can make work, you do it. The age of sure fire QBs is over. I'd probably say Peyton Manning was the last one. Maybe Luck but he's floundering in the worst division in football (not necessarily all his fault). If there is a guy you can work with, get him.
You need a guy that can do the following:
1. Take the easy stuff.
2. Make a handful of difficult throws a game.
Other than Rodgers who is doing ridiculous things with a criminally bad supporting cast. That's all these guys are doing. They aren't throwing it into tight windows 45 times a game. They take the easy stuff, which Reid can scheme for, and then they have to press in some bad situations.
If a guy can make the correct reads and accurately navigate a few bad situations, he can be successful. We don't need an all world guy, just a competent one.
|