Originally Posted by DRM08 (Post 16635696)

If he can contribute to 3 playoff runs like Sammy did, that would be a solid result for the Chiefs. Sammy missed a lot of regular season games, but he was a big time contributor in the playoffs. At least Toney is a lot cheaper than Watkins.

Originally Posted by TEX (Post 16635748)

Not really. He has an injury history. Watkins is actually a good comparison. Can be awesome when he plays, but... Ask yourself, have you wondered how he would have played the past couple of games had he been healthy? I have. Is Cincy a big game? Yes! Could Toney help? Most definitely! Is he gonna play? Who knows? Kinda just like the many game situations that we had with Sammy. :shrug:

Originally Posted by Chieftain (Post 16635782)

A comp 3rd round pick isn't nothing. You can get a very good player in the draft at that spot.

Originally Posted by BossChief (Post 16635644)

They don’t need him to make the playoffs, or even to get the 1 seed. So, if he can get a couple games in to gain timing that’s plenty. Let the hamstring fully heal and then put the foot on the gas in the postseason when we need him.

Originally Posted by DRM08 (Post 16635696)

If he can contribute to 3 playoff runs like Sammy did, that would be a solid result for the Chiefs. Sammy missed a lot of regular season games, but he was a big time contributor in the playoffs. At least Toney is a lot cheaper than Watkins.

Originally Posted by htismaqe (Post 16635767)

To be fair, the OP that Lzen was responding to said "waste of picks".

The answer to that, at least right now, is "not really".

They gave away practically nothing and he's making a tiny fraction of what Watkins did.

So if he turns out to give nothing more than Watkins did, it not only isn't a waste of picks, it's pretty good value considering what we gave up.

Originally Posted by TEX (Post 16635916)

Oh yeah, I was just talking about comparing Toney to Watkins is indeed an accurate comparison. I don't think it was a waste of trading the picks at all..I'd take that chance any day.

Originally Posted by Detoxing (Post 16635704)

Meh.

This is why i said we still need to draft a guy. His health is a question mark.

He can still be a great weapon though in a loaded WR room. So lets load this bitch up, eh?

Originally Posted by Chieftain (Post 16635661)

Kadarious Watkins. Waste of picks.

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 16635818)

Hows he gaining timing if he can't practice?

Originally Posted by dlphg9 (Post 16635929)

I kinda wish we would have traded for Chase Claypool. I think he'd be an absolute beast here, but also I'm glad we traded for Toney. I think he can be really good if he somehow becomes less injury prone. It's a risk that was worth it.

Originally Posted by dlphg9 (Post 16635929)

I kinda wish we would have traded for Chase Claypool. I think he'd be an absolute beast here, but also I'm glad we traded for Toney. I think he can be really good if he somehow becomes less injury prone. It's a risk that was worth it.